Choosing a driveway material might not sound exciting—until you’re knee-deep in options and costs. Two of the most common choices are tar and chip and asphalt, and if you’re not sure which one fits your needs, budget, and property style, you’re in the right place. Whether you’re resurfacing a rural lane or building a brand-new driveway, let’s break down the real-world pros and cons of each so you can make a smart, stress-free decision.
What’s the Difference Between Tar and Chip and Asphalt?
Both materials create sturdy, weather-resistant surfaces—but they do it differently. Tar and chip (also called chip seal) involves applying a hot liquid asphalt base, then layering crushed stone over it. The surface is then rolled to press the stone into place, creating a textured, rustic finish.
Asphalt, on the other hand, is a smooth, black mixture of bitumen and aggregates that’s poured and compacted to form a sleek surface. It’s often seen in suburban driveways, highways, and commercial lots.
Tar and Chip: The Pros and Cons
Why homeowners love it:
-
Cost-effective: On average, $2–$5 per square foot
-
Low maintenance: No sealcoating needed
-
Rustic aesthetic: Natural look that blends well with landscapes
-
Great traction: Especially useful in icy or wet conditions
What to consider:
-
Shorter lifespan than asphalt (typically 7–10 years)
-
Surface can be rougher for walking or biking
-
Fewer color consistency options than asphalt
Asphalt: The Pros and Cons
Why it’s a go-to choice:
-
Sleek finish: Classic, clean look for modern homes
-
Longer lifespan: 15–20 years with proper maintenance
-
Widely available: Easy to find contractors and materials
-
Smooth surface: Ideal for high traffic and snow removal
Things to keep in mind:
-
Higher cost: Around $4–$8 per square foot
-
Regular maintenance required: Sealcoating every 3–5 years
-
More prone to cracking without upkeep
Which One Should You Choose?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. If you’re going for curb appeal with a polished look and longer life span, asphalt might be worth the higher upfront and long-term maintenance cost. But if you’re working with a tighter budget or want something that blends with rural or rustic surroundings, tar and chip is a reliable, attractive alternative.
Also consider your climate. In areas like Ohio, where freeze-thaw cycles wreak havoc on pavement, the rough texture of tar and chip may offer better performance in the winter months. On the flip side, asphalt tends to be easier to plow and clean in snowy conditions.
Still unsure which surface is right for you? Take a closer look at our tar and chip service overview, learn more about asphalt paving benefits, dive into the full driveway paving process, or contact us today for a free estimate. Our team is here to guide you through every option and help you choose the right fit for your home or property.